Party wall agreements, which are legal documents that regulate construction and renovation work involving shared walls or boundaries between neighboring properties, are a crucial aspect of property law. While written agreements are the norm, questions often arise regarding the possibility of verbal party wall agreements. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the legalities and practical considerations surrounding verbal party wall agreements. Can they be legally binding, and if so, what are the potential pitfalls and challenges associated with such agreements?
Definition and Purpose - A party wall agreement, also known as a party wall award, is a legal document that outlines the rights and responsibilities of property owners when one intends to carry out construction work that could affect a shared wall or boundary.
Types of Party Wall Agreements - There are three main types of party wall agreements: party wall notice, party wall agreement, and party wall award. The type depends on the nature and scope of the construction work.
The Party Wall Act 1996 - In the United Kingdom, the Party Wall Act 1996 governs party wall matters. This legislation sets out the requirements for serving notices, disputes, and the necessity of a party wall agreement.
Written Notices - The Act requires property owners to serve written notices to their neighbors before commencing construction work that affects a party wall.
Adjoining Owner's Response - The adjoining owner can respond to the notice by either consenting or dissenting. Dissenting leads to the appointment of a party wall surveyor.
Party Wall Surveyor - In the event of a dispute, a party wall surveyor is appointed to prepare a party wall award, a formal agreement detailing the construction work and its impact.
Common Practice - Verbal agreements are a common practice in various aspects of life, including informal matters between neighbors.
Lack of Legal Formality - One of the challenges with verbal agreements is their informal nature, which can lead to misunderstandings and disputes.
Ambiguity - Verbal agreements may lack clarity and specificity, making it difficult to determine the rights and obligations of each party.
Common Law Principles - Common law principles often recognize verbal agreements, but their enforceability can be complex.
Statutory Requirements - The Party Wall Act 1996 explicitly requires written notices, suggesting a preference for formalized agreements.
Contract Law - In legal terms, a party wall agreement is essentially a contract. Contracts are generally enforceable if they meet certain criteria.
Consideration and Intent - For a verbal agreement to be legally binding, it must involve an offer, acceptance, consideration, and the clear intent to create legal relations.
Lack of Documentation - Verbal agreements lack the written record that is often necessary for evidence in case of disputes.
Dispute Resolution - In the event of a dispute between neighbors regarding a verbal agreement, it may be challenging to establish the terms of the agreement and resolve the issue.
Ambiguity and Misunderstanding - Verbal agreements are susceptible to misunderstandings and misinterpretations, leading to disagreements and legal conflicts.
Evidence Burden - Parties seeking to enforce a verbal agreement may face difficulties in providing sufficient evidence to support their claims.
The Pragmatic Approach - While verbal agreements may lack the legal formality of written agreements, they can be practical for minor, low-impact works where neighborly trust is high.
The Importance of Communication - Open and transparent communication between neighbors can help avoid disputes and ensure clarity, even when formal agreements are not in place.
Verbal party wall agreements exist in a legal gray area. While they may be recognized in certain common law principles, statutory requirements and the formalized nature of party wall agreements, as governed by the Party Wall Act 1996, suggest a preference for written notices and agreements. However, in practice, neighbors often rely on verbal agreements for minor works where trust is strong. Nevertheless, the lack of documentation and the potential for ambiguity and disputes underscore the importance of formalizing agreements in writing when undertaking construction work that impacts shared walls or boundaries. Legal advice and open communication between neighbors remain key to successful party wall arrangements.
For more information call us at 020 3875 9279 or email us.
Adam Joseph Chartered Surveyors is a trading name of Sherling & Partners Limited
Website: https://www.sherlingandpartners.co.uk
Registered Address: Balfour House, Suite 206, 741 High Road, North Finchley N12 0BP
Company Number: 10621087
VAT Number: 265816036
We serve clients in East Ham, Putney, North London, Essex, Finchley,
Birmingham, Richmond and Cambridge.
Our services includes Party Wall Surveyor & Level 3 Building Survey